top of page
Search

Is Turning Back A Failure?

Oct 27
6 min read

After last week’s substack promising I’d start sharing more educational content covering all of the topics as to why mountain rescue are so stretched, this week I thought I’d delve deeper on how to know when to call it a day and turn around.

Yeah you’ve put the effort in, your legs are tired, and the thought of heading back down without reaching the summit feels a little bit rubbish. I get it because I’ve been there a number of times, but one of the most important skills you can learn in the mountains isn’t how to get to the top, it’s knowing when not to.



How Do You Know When It’s Time to Turn Around?


There isn’t one universal rule. Every mountain, route, group and day is different. But there are some things I’d always pay attention to:


1. The weather is getting worse


You don’t need to wait until the weather is horrendous to decide it’s time to change plans. Perhaps the forecast this morning suggested a decent morning, but the wind is picking up, the cloud is coming down or visibility is getting noticeably worse.


As I touched on last week, conditions on a mountain can be very different from those at the car park, and they can change quickly. Strong winds can make exposed ground much more challenging, while poor visibility can make navigation harder and increase the risk of losing your way.


If you’re relying on the weather improving, ask yourself what happens if it doesn’t. Would you still be comfortable continuing if conditions got worse? Do you know how to navigate if you can no longer see the path clearly? Are you equipped and experienced enough for what might be ahead?


If the answers are making you uncomfortable, it’s worth stopping and reassessing before you get into a more exposed or difficult section.


2. You’re running out of time or daylight


When you’re planning a hike, it’s easy to focus on how long it will take to reach the summit. But don’t forget you always need to account for the entire day, including the descent, breaks, slower than expected progress and any unexpected delays.


If you’re already behind schedule, don’t assume you’ll somehow make up the time later. And please don’t forget your headtorch. It’s an essential bit of kit, but having one doesn’t mean you should casually plan to finish in the dark.


If you’re moving more slowly than expected and daylight is running short, it may be time to reconsider your objective. The important thing is to make that decision while you still have options, rather than waiting until you’re under pressure.


3. You or someone in your group is struggling


This one can be harder to spot, particularly when everyone is trying to be brave and not make a fuss. Perhaps someone is unusually quiet, falling behind, struggling to keep warm or finding the terrain much harder than expected. You may even find that you’re the one who’s exhausted, your concentration is slipping, or you’re starting to make mistakes you wouldn’t normally make.


Fatigue can affect your judgement, coordination and ability to make good decisions. If you’re already tired, cold or hungry, even a relatively straightforward section of a route can start to feel much more difficult.


Check in with yourself and the people around you. Have you eaten? Had enough to drink? Are you warm enough? Is everyone still happy and comfortable with the plan?


There’s absolutely no shame in admitting you’re struggling. If someone in your group needs to turn around, that deserves to be taken seriously rather than treated as an inconvenience.


4. The terrain is more difficult than you expected


Sometimes a route looks perfectly manageable when you’re planning it at home, but feels very different when you’re actually standing on the ground. Perhaps the path is steeper, more exposed or more technical than you anticipated. The rock may be wet and slippery, or the route involves scrambling that you don’t feel confident tackling.


This is why understanding the route before you set off is so important. Look beyond the distance and elevation gain. Think about the terrain, exposure, navigation challenges and the skills you’ll need along the way. If you arrive at a section and realise it’s beyond your ability or comfort level, you don’t have to push on just because it’s part of the original plan.


Stop and assess the situation. Consider whether there’s a safe alternative or whether turning around is the better option. There’s a difference between feeling challenged and being in over your head.


5. Something just doesn’t feel right


This one is harder to explain, but I think it’s worth mentioning. Sometimes you can’t immediately put your finger on what’s wrong. You might notice that the conditions feel more challenging than expected, that you’re uncomfortable with the route ahead, or that you’re having to work much harder to stay on top of things.


That feeling isn’t always a sign that something bad is about to happen, but it is a good reason to pause, take stock and think carefully about what you’re doing. You’re allowed to make a cautious decision simply because the situation no longer feels right for you and your group.



Make the Decision Before You Reach the Point of No Return


One of the most useful things you can do is think about your turnaround point before you leave home.


When you plan your route, consider what might make you change your plans.

For example:


  • If the weather deteriorates beyond what you’re comfortable with, you’ll reassess or turn back.

  • If you’re significantly behind schedule, you’ll shorten the route rather than rush.

  • If you reach terrain that’s beyond your ability or the group’s experience, you won’t continue just to reach the summit.

  • If someone is struggling, you’ll put their wellbeing ahead of the original objective.


These aren’t rigid rules that will work for every situation. They’re a starting point to help you think ahead rather than making every decision under pressure.


It’s much easier to agree that you’ll turn around if the conditions aren’t right when you’re warm, rested and planning at home than when you’re cold, tired and only twenty minutes from the top.


If you’re hiking with other people, always talk about it together. Make sure everyone knows that changing the plan is an option, not something they need to feel embarrassed about.


What if You’ve Already Gone Too Far?


Sometimes you won’t realise things are going wrong until you’re already in a difficult situation. If that happens, try not to panic or let the pressure of reaching your original destination cloud your judgement. Stop somewhere safe if you can, assess the conditions and work out what your options are. Think about your location, the route ahead, the weather, daylight and the capabilities of everyone in your group.


If you’re unsure how to proceed, don’t keep pushing forward simply because you don’t know what else to do. Depending on the situation, retracing your steps or taking a different route may be safer, but turning around isn’t automatically the right answer if the descent itself presents greater risks. This is where knowing your route, understanding a map and having the skills to navigate really matter.


If you’re in genuine trouble, injured, lost or unable to get yourself to safety, call 999 or 112, ask for the police and request Mountain Rescue. Don’t delay because you’re embarrassed or worried about bothering them. Taking responsibility for yourself doesn’t mean refusing help when you need it.



Let’s Stop Treating the Summit as the Only Success


I want more women to feel confident heading into the mountains. I want you to challenge yourself, learn new skills, discover what you’re capable of and experience all the brilliant things that come with spending time outdoors. But I also want you to understand that being confident in the mountains doesn’t mean being fearless, knowing everything or always achieving what you set out to do.


It means being able to make sensible decisions, even when they’re not the decisions you were hoping to make. It means knowing when to keep going, when to change the plan and when to call it a day. And it means understanding that getting home safely is always more important than standing on a particular summit.


So, the next time you’re out on a hike and you find yourself debating whether to carry on, take a moment to look at the conditions and think about the route ahead. Check in with yourself and your group. Be honest about how you’re feeling, and ask whether reaching the top is worth the risks involved.


If the answer is no, turn around. You haven’t failed. You’ve learned something, made a decision and given yourself the chance to come back another day. There will always be another mountain, another route and another opportunity to reach that summit.


The mountains aren’t going anywhere 🩵

See you out there,

Lucy x

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page